Toby Arnold  
Starting Pitcher | Owen Sound Crusaders

Pitching
Arnold can get into trouble with walks, and there's concern about him being able to maintain his stuff over the whole season. His fastball is just average, and therefore he relies heavily on placing it in different parts of the strike zone or setting it up with his slider. Arnold also has a decent changeup. He generates few groundballs, though he generally keeps the ball in the park. He attacks lefties and righties with similar success.

Defense & Hitting
He has quick feet and can catch runners napping at first or second base. He tends to fall off slightly to the first-base side of the mound, making him vulnerable to bunts toward third base. He makes up for that minor flaw by being aggressive in fielding his position. Arnold is a surpisingly good hitting pitcher. And I'm not sure you can say this about a pitcher, but Arnold has some pop in his swing.

2025 Outlook
I really like what this guy brings to the table.

          -- Moostard Nyman

 

Player Skills Yearly Scouting Report Cards
Year Team AS EN CO HR GF vL Hm Sc CL FB CU SI SL CB SC KN Age Exp Delivery Slot CH PH SP FA Nyman Rating
2010 POR 76 67 35 80 43 42 49 51 47 57 55 0 53 33 0 0 20 0 Overhand Low Minors 0 0 0 36 290
2011 POR 84 65 39 83 43 42 49 51 47 57 55 0 53 33 0 0 21 0 Overhand Low Minors 0 0 0 38 303
2012 POR 84 67 51 89 43 42 49 51 47 61 55 0 53 33 0 0 22 0 Overhand Low Minors 0 0 0 42 329
2013 POR 84 68 64 91 43 42 49 51 47 61 55 0 57 33 0 0 23 0 Overhand AA/AAA 0 0 0 46 349
2014 POR 84 69 70 95 43 42 49 51 47 72 55 0 57 33 0 0 24 0 Overhand Low Minors 0 0 0 49 373
2015 POR 84 71 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 72 63 0 61 33 0 0 25 0 Overhand Active 0 0 0 52 391
2016 POR 84 72 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 75 65 0 70 33 0 0 26 1 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 405
2017 POR 84 73 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 75 68 0 74 33 0 0 27 2 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 412
2018 POR 84 73 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 76 68 0 77 33 0 0 28 3 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 415
2019 POR 84 73 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 76 70 0 77 40 0 0 29 4 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 426
2020 POR 84 71 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 76 70 0 79 44 0 0 30 5 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 430
2021 POR 84 73 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 76 70 0 79 47 0 0 31 6 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 435
2022 OWE 84 71 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 76 70 0 79 49 0 0 32 7 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 434
2023 OWE 84 70 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 77 70 0 80 49 0 0 33 8 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 434
2024 OWE 84 73 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 77 72 0 80 49 0 0 34 9 Overhand Active 0 0 0 53 439
2025 OWE 84 71 74 95 43 42 49 51 47 77 72 0 80 49 0 0 35 10 Overhand Active 0 0 0 51 436
Ratings Delta   -2                             +1 +1           -2 -3

CBL Collegiate League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team W L Sv Hld G GS QS CG IP AIP H HR BB SO IR IRS K/9 K/BB Whip Avg Slg LHB RHB ERA
2008 18 UAA 10 10 0 0 35 35 8 2 198 5.2 203 19 218 136 0 0 6.18 0.62 2.13 .271 .411 .304 .252 7.55
2009 19 UAA 10 17 0 0 35 35 2 8 206.1 6.0 264 32 241 125 0 0 5.46 0.52 2.45 .314 .484 .347 .296 9.12
2010 20 UAA 18 7 0 0 35 35 11 11 235.1 6.2 269 34 192 148 0 0 5.67 0.77 1.96 .287 .450 .307 .273 6.35
Totals     38 34 0 0 105 105 21 21 639.2 6.0 736 85 651 409 0 0 5.76 0.63 2.17 .291 .450 .319 .275 7.62

CBL Pioneer League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team W L Sv Hld G GS QS CG IP AIP H HR BB SO IR IRS K/9 K/BB Whip Avg Slg LHB RHB ERA
2011 21 PCRD 3 12 0 0 19 19 5 2 108.2 5.2 115 22 66 39 0 0 3.24 0.59 1.67 .269 .484 .269 .269 6.21
2012 22 PCRD 8 22 0 0 41 41 10 0 218.1 5.1 249 43 114 78 0 0 3.22 0.68 1.66 .287 .489 .303 .274 5.57
2014 24 PCRD 20 10 0 0 33 33 25 1 212.1 6.1 196 22 52 113 0 0 4.79 2.17 1.17 .240 .373 .256 .228 3.18
2015 25 PCRD 26 11 0 0 41 41 25 0 271.1 6.2 236 30 48 158 0 0 5.25 3.29 1.05 .229 .377 .234 .225 3.28
Totals     57 55 0 0 134 134 65 3 810.2 6.0 796 117 280 388 0 0 4.31 1.39 1.33 .253 .421 .264 .246 4.27

CBL Major League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team W L Sv Hld G GS QS CG IP AIP H HR BB SO IR IRS K/9 K/BB Whip Avg Slg LHB RHB ERA
2015 25 POR 5 6 0 1 26 8 4 2 109.2 4.1 104 15 24 43 11 0 3.54 1.79 1.17 .249 .412 .300 .215 3.20
2016 26 POR 14 9 1 0 32 26 12 3 172 5.1 153 27 38 79 0 0 4.13 2.08 1.11 .236 .414 .275 .207 4.45
2017 27 POR 15 10 0 0 32 32 19 0 201.1 6.1 208 36 46 90 0 0 4.03 1.96 1.26 .262 .453 .283 .243 4.25
2018 28 POR 11 13 2 1 36 27 14 4 195 5.1 204 44 34 103 6 1 4.75 3.03 1.22 .268 .499 .277 .261 4.99
2019 29 POR 11 3 0 0 20 20 12 1 127 6.1 135 23 29 53 0 0 3.76 1.83 1.29 .271 .470 .278 .266 4.11
2020 30 POR 7 6 0 0 35 10 1 1 126 3.2 155 29 31 68 13 4 4.86 2.19 1.48 .299 .523 .353 .259 6.00
2021 31 POR 17 10 0 0 32 32 17 3 221.2 7.0 219 40 31 105 0 0 4.27 3.39 1.13 .256 .460 .271 .245 4.10
2022 32 OWE 11 10 6 7 43 22 11 1 165.1 4.0 215 26 28 84 14 4 4.58 3.00 1.47 .309 .484 .322 .296 4.79
2023 33 OWE 2 3 20 3 39 0 0 0 47.1 1.1 43 6 19 19 22 6 3.63 1.00 1.32 .240 .430 .263 .223 3.61
2024 34 OWE 7 7 13 0 32 8 6 1 96.2 3.0 93 18 12 48 8 3 4.49 4.00 1.09 .254 .448 .274 .230 3.72
2025 35 OWE 15 8 2 0 36 31 21 2 210 6.0 214 33 34 91 5 3 3.90 2.68 1.18 .263 .437 .284 .247 3.73
Totals     115 85 44 12 363 216 117 18 1672 4.2 1743 297 326 783 79 21 4.21 2.40 1.24 .266 .460 .293 .248 4.33

Transfer History for Toby Arnold
Date Transferred with Arnold To New Club In Exchange For To Old Club
July 31 2022 Mc Yett
Leon Lemon
 Owen Sound Crusaders Sherry Whittle
Sukhyum Harris
1st Rd 2023 (22nd pick)
 Port Hope Battery

Toby Arnold's Career Highlights
Year Details
2010 1st round - 8th overall selection by Port Hope Battery in the 2010 Amateur Draft

Toby Arnold's Injury History
Date Injured Days Injured Injury Impact  
August 5, 2015 16 Strained elbow ligament 11%  
May 7, 2019 52 Pinched ulnar nerve 100% Disabled List
May 28, 2020 8 Bruised ribs 1%  
June 26, 2025 8 Sore rotator cuff 16%  

Toby Arnold's Comparable Players
Player Names
Johnny Carrington 90.4%        

Tip - Click on the club abbreviation to get further details and history.
Transfer history draft picks in brackets indicate the actual pick number in the draft wasn't determined at the time of the deal being made.
Report Cards generated by Biorhythm v2.7.82 on Fri Aug 12 01:15:47 CEST 2011
Report card data printed in red denotes that player was in the top two percent for that category and year. Blue data denotes membership to the bottom two percent.