Hitting
Extra always has been a line-drive hitter who uses the entire field. The Retired or Inactive Players do tend to sit Extra when the opposing team throws a lefty. It's no secret he can't touch the left-handed breaking ball.
Baserunning & Defense
When you play Extra you're not putting him in for his glove. His arm is accurate enough. His speed is below average and he's not a threat to steal.
2025 Outlook
One has to wonder what Mcnalley Extra is doing in AA. In all honesty, he could use a lot of work on the fundamentals in the low minors.
-- Emu Nyman, AA/AAA Scout