Hitting
This guy can't hit a watermelon with a lampost. Horgan always has been a line-drive hitter who uses the entire field. He hits righthanders and lefthanders with equal consistency.
Baserunning & Defense
Horgan isn't fast, but he's a heady baserunner who rarely gets thrown out. Horgan is a poor defensive catcher. He isn't very mobile or adept at blocking balls in the dirt. Runners take advantage of his weak arm.
2025 Outlook
One has to wonder what Muddy Horgan is doing in AA. In all honesty, he could use a lot of work on the fundamentals in the low minors.
-- Emu Nyman, AA/AAA Scout