Montae Tohill  
Third Baseman | PEI Argonauts

Hitting
In past seasons, Tohill has been a bit of a liability with men on base. He hits righthanders and lefthanders with equal consistency.

Baserunning & Defense
His arm and range are average, and he has a tendency to get lazy with his feet. Tohill is an intelligent baserunner with average speed, but he's not a basestealing threat.

          -- Moostard Nyman

 

Player Skills Yearly Scouting Report Cards
Year Team POS CH PH SP GF PL vL Hm Sc CL Age Exp Slot FA AS Qualified Positions Nyman Rating
2012 WIN 3B 60 55 70 57 52 53 54 45 52 22 0 Low Minors 61 66 . 305
2013 WIN 3B 70 64 70 57 52 53 54 45 52 23 0 Low Minors 66 67 . 337
2014 WIN 3B 77 76 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 24 0 Active 73 71 . 370
2015 WIN 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 25 1 Active 81 71 . 373
2016 WIN 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 26 2 Active 81 71 . 372
2017 WIN 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 27 3 Active 81 71 . 371
2018 WIN 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 28 4 Active 81 71 . 370
2019 WIN 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 29 5 Active 81 71 . 369
2020 GRR 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 30 6 Active 81 71 . 368
2021 GRR 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 31 7 Active 81 71 . 367
2022 GRR 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 32 8 Active 81 71 . 366
2023 GRR 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 33 9 Active 81 71 . 365
2024 GRR 3B 77 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 34 10 Active 79 71 . 364
2025 PEI 3B 76 78 71 57 52 53 54 45 52 35 11 Active 79 71 . 361
Ratings Delta -1                 +1 +1         -3

CBL Collegiate League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI RC BB SO K/BB SB CS OBP SLG Pro LHP RHP E Pct AVG
2010 20 UBB 159 684 176 229 53 1 23 127 159 146 77 0.527 78 11 .459 .516 .975 .341 .332 12 .966 .335
2011 21 UBB 160 658 189 231 55 1 27 171 174 153 73 0.477 74 2 .478 .561 1.04 .397 .325 22 .943 .351
2012 22 UBB 161 669 186 240 56 2 34 185 188 139 70 0.504 77 3 .470 .601 1.07 .343 .368 13 .967 .359
Totals     480 2011 551 700 164 4 84 483 521 438 220 0.502 229 16 .468 .559 1.03 .361 .341 47 .959 .348

CBL Pioneer League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI RC BB SO K/BB SB CS OBP SLG Pro LHP RHP E Pct AVG
2013 23 PPER 158 639 120 186 40 2 31 78 118 75 73 0.973 33 0 .370 .505 .875 .266 .302 10 .972 .291
Totals     158 639 120 186 40 2 31 78 118 75 73 0.973 33 0 .369 .505 .874 .266 .302 10 .972 .291

CBL Major League Yearly Statistical Records
Year Age Team G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI RC BB SO K/BB SB CS OBP SLG Pro LHP RHP E Pct AVG
2014 24 WPG 132 458 44 112 16 2 21 51 54 22 80 3.636 4 0 .288 .426 .714 .313 .218 8 .974 .245
2015 25 WPG 162 651 90 177 45 2 34 94 103 43 112 2.605 10 0 .324 .504 .828 .285 .268 5 .988 .272
2016 26 WPG 162 617 80 154 35 1 26 65 76 30 99 3.300 10 0 .291 .436 .727 .259 .245 6 .986 .250
2017 27 WPG 160 658 86 190 39 0 32 87 105 36 90 2.500 15 0 .329 .494 .823 .274 .297 4 .990 .289
2018 28 WPG 162 621 74 152 34 0 23 58 70 28 86 3.071 6 0 .282 .411 .693 .304 .216 1 .997 .245
2019 29 WPG 162 658 105 181 39 2 39 85 107 38 72 1.895 13 1 .323 .518 .841 .258 .280 4 .989 .275
2020 30 GRR 162 642 71 157 28 1 25 68 72 28 80 2.857 9 0 .279 .408 .687 .237 .247 5 .987 .245
2021 31 GRR 162 690 92 201 31 1 30 78 104 32 92 2.875 13 0 .324 .470 .794 .358 .271 7 .984 .291
2022 32 GRR 162 656 87 184 50 0 29 92 101 34 75 2.206 8 0 .315 .489 .804 .273 .283 3 .993 .280
2023 33 GRR 162 665 90 171 45 1 39 98 99 37 72 1.946 13 0 .299 .504 .803 .269 .253 4 .990 .257
2024 34 GRR 162 653 98 187 37 0 36 91 108 40 66 1.650 17 1 .333 .508 .841 .307 .279 13 .971 .286
2025 35 PEI 160 627 87 160 28 5 24 76 80 40 80 2.000 17 0 .301 .431 .732 .257 .254 16 .959 .255
Totals     1910 7596 1004 2026 427 15 358 943 1079 408 1004 2.461 135 2 .308 .468 .776 .282 .261 76 .984 .267

Transfer History for Montae Tohill
Date Transferred with Tohill To New Club In Exchange For To Old Club
April 7 2025 Scott Sidden
Ryan Woodall
3rd Rd 2025 - 73rd pick
PEI Argonauts Eroni Brendle
Doug Velez
Thomas Cooper
Stephen Greene
Brad Neame
1st Rd 2025 - 23rd pick
Grand Rapids Red Dogs

Montae Tohill's Career Highlights
Year Details
2012 1st round - 5th overall selection by Winnipeg Cobras in the 2012 Amateur Draft
2018 Gold Glove Award
2021 Farmers League All Star
2022 Gold Glove Award
2024 Farmers League All Star

Montae Tohill's Records
Most Doubles in an Extra Inning Game Individual Batting Game Records 4 - for Grand Rapids on July 22, 2022 Versus St Paul

Montae Tohill's Injury History
Date Injured Days Injured Injury Impact  
June 6, 2017 8 Pulled groin muscle 14%  
April 10, 2020 16 Sprained thumb 12%  
July 9, 2023 4 Bruised foot 4%  
October 4, 2025 11 Pulled groin muscle 16%  

Montae Tohill's Comparable Players
Player Names
Shane Vaikona 96.8% Ian Saltiel 95.8% Kit Karlovacko 95.4% Griphen Breedan 95.2% Taj Bredesen 94.8%

Tip - Click on the club abbreviation to get further details and history.
Transfer history draft picks in brackets indicate the actual pick number in the draft wasn't determined at the time of the deal being made.
Report Cards generated by Biorhythm v2.7.82 on Fri Aug 12 01:15:47 CEST 2011
Report card data printed in red denotes that player was in the top two percent for that category and year. Blue data denotes membership to the bottom two percent.